07 July 2019

Can't Stop Thinking About Weapons

Predictably enough, when I set down to whittle the 5e rules down to something that I'm interested in running, one of the first things that I take a look at are the rules for weapons.

Have I actually laid out what my issues with the weapons list in 5e is? It's both boring and long, with obvious traps in damage and functionality, and somehow also lacking in anything resembling interest. If you want to do a big long list of weaponry, you can do better by looking at one of the Warhammer 40k weapon lists, with all of its modifiers and finnicky bonii, or you can look directly at FantasyCraft, which takes great pains to make each weapon type distinct through the liberal use of feats and class features.

5e doesn't do either, which is why I always want to get rid of it. 5e isn't really a game about whether you should bring a sword or an axe or a spear, and I kind of want it to be.



 So here's a little something inspired by much-maligned weapon speed rules in 1E.



Weapon Lengths 


The basic idea is that, in a melee, those with longer weapons get to strike first. They always make the attack roll first. Unfortunately, longer weapons also need more space to operate.

There's also a difference between 'thrusting' and 'swinging' weapons.

Thrusting weapons attack in  a straight line, can skewer through enemies to strike enemies behind them, and can pin enemies to walls.

Swinging weapons, like axes, can cleave through all enemies around them, push enemies away from them in any direction. Unfortunately, if you try and use a swinging weapon in an enclosed space, you suffer disadvantage on your attacks.

Swords, uniquely, can both thrust and swing. They are much more expensive than any other weapon type, however.

So now real-world tactics can apply. If you have a spear, you'll want to line your enemies up behind one another, and fight in narrower corridors where your superior weapon length lets you keep them somewhat at bay. A superior fighter will still overcome you, but at least you have the first strike.

If you're operating mostly on your own, or in disorganized and chaotic melees, you can swing your axe with reckless abandon in a big open area. But tight, confined areas are not great for you. You're at your best with lots of room to manipulate your foes.

If you've got a sword, you can thrust in tight quarters or swing in more open ones. It's not as long as a spear, of course, but you can't have it all.

So now there are tradeoffs and benefits to each type of weapon, and different kinds of warriors are going to want to use different types of weaponry.

I'm still working on how to use skewering, cleaving, pushing, and pinning in 5e. I'm thinking as a bonus to when you beat your enemy's AC by more than 5, you get to use one of your weapon's benefits. So if your enemy's AC is 15 and you roll a 21, you can skewer behind them with your spear, or force them backwards with your axe (possibly off a cliff or into a fire, or whatever). Cleaving lets you hit multiple foes at once. Pinning lets you keep your enemies in place.

Larger enemies need more space, but also always attack first. A giant is going to need a lot of room to swing its club around. Creatures with natural weapons probably don't need a lot of room- that troll sure is dangerous in a cramped warren...

Monks should just flat out be able to strike first, since they're movie martial artists and one has to imagine in a world full of swords they've practiced how to step into a guard or whatever. If you have a different conception of monks in your world, feel free to change this. Maybe they strike like a shortsword. Up to you.

None of this is playtested. Use at your own risk.


This also works pretty well with another system I've been working on, and something I've posted here before:




Weapon Damage by Size

So in this scheme, one-handed weapons do 1d6 damage and two-handed weapons do 1d8 damage. If you're a Fighter, Barbarian, Ranger, or Paladin (the warrior-type classes of 5e), then your one-handed weapons deal 1d8 damage and your two-handed weapons deal 1d10.

Light and/or Finesse weapons drop the size down one die, so a two-handed finesse weapon wielded by a non-warrior deals 1d6 damage, and a Fighter's two-handed hammer toss deals 1d8 damage.

Light weapons can be thrown, and Finesse weapons allow the wielder to choose between Strength and Dexterity when making melee attacks.

Weapons are further differentiated by their critical effects:
Swords and daggers critical on 19-20.
Axes step up their die size on a critical hit (so a two-handed axe crit by a Barbarian deals 1d12 damage)
Blunt weapons stun their foes (DC equal to 10+damage). The wielder may also optionally push / knock that enemy prone.

If you combine the two, I feel like you've got a pretty robust system.

As a DM, you'll need to be fair with adjucating when various weapons will or won't work. Tight spaces can mess with a sword, but being surrounded is bad news for a spear. People can hide underneath things if a reaver with an axe is coming at them, and goblins might retreat into tight warrens to escape a barbarian.


As usual, let me know what you think. I may not respond to many, but I read every single one of them, and it always makes my day to know what people think about what I'm working on.

I'm going to try and be better about sharing what I'm writing about instead of churning endlessly throught Notepad++ tabs, deleting everything, and starting over like I'm accustomed to doing... if for no other reason than maybe sharing some of my ideas can get them to stick a bit.


29 comments:

  1. Good work.I really appreciate it.

    Infinity Limo Car is providing Limo Service DC , Dulles Limo Service.

    Book Car Service Washington DC & Car Service DC at affordable prices in Washington DC, Virginia and Maryland.

    Wedding limousine Service!
    Make your Day Special with Wedding Limo, Wedding Limo Service & Wedding Limo Hire for prom nights.

    Airport Services:
    Airport Transportation near me
    Car Service DC
    Car Service Washington DC

    Services Demanded by celebrities & famous personalities:
    Hummer limo
    Hummer Limo Rental .
    Limo Rental Prices.

    Shuttle & Bus Services:
    Suburban SUV Rental
    Shuttle Service
    Limo Bus Rental

    Get Free Quote
    Reserve Limo Online Now for Luxury Tour!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well Done! Highly recommended.

    WashingtonDC Limo Car is facilitaing with Luxury Car Service, Limo Service DC in Maryland, Virginia & Washington DC at cheap Limo Rental Prices.

    Prom Nights Service:

    Prom Limo Service ensures best Prom Limo Hire servive.
    Enjoy Cheap Limo Service.

    We are providing Airport Transfers to Washington DC, Maryland & Virginia.

    .BWI Airport Limousine And Car Service
    .BWI Car Service .BWI Limo Service.
    . Car Service to Dulles
    . IAD Car Service . Dulles Airport Limousine Service.
    . Dulles Airport Transportation
    . Car Service to Dulles.

    Hire our Chauffeur Service
    for your luxury travel with professional Chauffeur.
    Chauffeur Car Service
    Chauffeur Service near me!

    Get Free Quote
    Reserve Limo Online Now for Luxury Tour!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Informative ideas. Keep it up!

    Vertri Limo provides one of the best Limo Service DC, Limousine Service in the Washington DC,

    Are You Looking forLimousine Service near me:

    . Cheap Limo Service
    . Prom Limo Service
    . Car Service Washington DC.

    Airport Transportation all over the Washington DC:
    Dulles Airport Transportation is the best Airport Limo Service of Vertri Limo.

    Airport Transfers service across all over the Washington DC.

    Car Service to DC
    DCA Car Service
    Limo Service DC
    Airport Transfers

    Book an Online trip to the Washington DC Airport!

    Airport Transportation Dulles
    Shuttle Service or Dulles Airport Transportation.

    Get Free Quote
    Reserve Limo Online for Luxury Tour!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bigg Boss 14 Salman Khan to host the show in September.
    Bigg Boss 14
    Bigg Boss 14 Episodes
    Bigg Boss 14 Contestants List

    Copy your video URL from youtube to mp3 that you need to download.
    youtube to mp3
    youtube downloader

    Video Shadi Mubarak Star Plus Watch Hindi Serial Full Episodes Online.
    Shadi Mubarak

    Video Pinjara Khubsurti Ka Colors Tv Hindi Series Video Episodes.
    Pinjara Khubsurti Ka

    ReplyDelete

  5. First National Equities Limited (FNEL) is a leading online stock trading and brokerage firm in Pakistan We bring you the most authentic data and latest updates of PSX.

    pakistan stock exchange live index
    pakistan stock exchange news
    stock exchange brokerage
    stock broker
    trading
    Pakistan share market

    ReplyDelete
  6. There are two very important things that come to our mind when we think about a home inspection:
     Is it safe to let a stranger inside our house?
     Is spending money on this worth it?
    We have the answers for you. While residing in Atlanta, and along with many options to choose from, Champia Real Estate is the best choice for you. While spending on getting a home inspection from them, it is affirmative that in whole Atlanta home inspection prices are very affordable as compared to the quality of services they are providing. They make sure that the money you are spending is worth the hustle. They involve you in the process to give you proper insights and maintenance tips. Atlanta GA, home inspectors sent by Champia are certified professionals and they come with insurance plus different sorts of residential warranties so you can totally rely on them when it comes to these two terms which can make you worry about the process.

    ReplyDelete
  7. When it comes to Home Inspections Atlanta Georgia has the best inspection company named as Champia Real Estate Inspections because they were founded in 1987 and since then they have been serving with excellence. They have over 50000 completed inspections in their portfolio and have diverse expertise. This real estate inspection company deals with residential as well as commercial home inspections and have a delivery time of reports in 24 hours for residential inspections and around four days for commercial inspections. Their quick and efficient service plus their customer satisfaction rate is what makes their best Home Inspection Marietta GAand other states of Atlanta has to offer. Among many others, the three key qualities that make them prominent are their experience, certifications and their affordability.
    They come with additional warranties for residential inspections only so that the homeowner is comfortable with the services and the person that they are letting inside their house.

    ReplyDelete
  8. When it comes to Real Estate Inspections Champia real estate inspections have the best services to offer. As they have the best home inspectors in Atlanta who have the necessary expertise to perform a successful home inspection and adequate experience. They have completed over 50000 inspections and a great number of positive reviews as a proof that you can rely on them completely when it comes to the healthy environment of your home. They provide a number of warranties as well for residential inspection so you can be relaxed about the outcome of the inspection. For residential inspection, they give 24 hours ultimatum and schedule and complete the appointments and reports at the exact time. The home inspectors at Champia are very adaptive and care about your comfort. They love it when you are an active part of the home inspection because in this way you can get to know more about the details and they can give you more tips about the maintenance about how to take care of your house after the inspection process.

    ReplyDelete
  9. When it comes to home inspection Atlanta ga has the best home inspection company who will deal with all your problems relating to the health of your house. One of the very common problems that are present in almost every house either known or unknown is the presence of mold inside the house. Mold is present around us everywhere so it is nearly impossible to eradicate them completely unless it is some heavy mechanical equipment. They are present in the air in the form of spores and spread on moist environments. It is a good new and bad one too because if you have moist surfaces at your home, there is a good chance that mold is present around you too and it can cause many harms to your health. It is also a reason to worsen present medical conditions like allergies and respiratory diseases. Champia offers the best mold inspection Atlanta has. They have necessary expertise and equipment to deal with this problem and help you get rid of it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. In Atlanta, Real Estate Inspections are an important part to be included in your property maintenance routine because as much as getting your painted or getting apparent repairs done is important, a home inspection is important in order to know if your house is safe for you and your family to live or not. There are many factors that are hazardous for your family such as high levels of radon inside your home, mold problems, water leaks, termites, air pollution and other factors that pose a threat to your health. A known name for Home Inspection Atlanta has is Champia Real Estate Inspection which deals in home inspection as well as commercial inspections. They were founded in 1987 and have a record of over 50,000 completed inspections and a completion time of 24 hours which is pretty quick. Not to forget their multiple warranties on home inspection which makes it even more reliable.

    ReplyDelete
  11. In Atlanta real estate inspection is considered an important factor before proceeding with that property, whether its a workplace or your home. The fact that wherever you are going to spend the maximum of your time should be healthy for you. While we take care of the cleanliness of the space we are working in, taking care of the air quality around us is important as well. One of the most dangerous toxin that is present in the air around us is radon. Radon gas is present in the air around us but when it gets trapped around us inside our property where we breath, it can get stuck inside our system and its prolonged inhalation is the leading cause of lung cancer in non smokers. Champia real estate inspections offer best Radon testing in Atlanta as they have the necessary equipment and experienced professional with relevant expertise and a huge number of positive reviews so one can completely rely on them regarding your safety and satisfying results.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Atlanta home inspection is a booming industry because of the many cases found inside the homes which were proven to affect the health of the residents and the structure of the house. House inspection companies help out the residents in finding out what is wrong with the place they are residing or even if they are buying that property. Champia Real Estate inspections have the best home inspectors Atlanta has to offer because of their vast experience and their expertise in this field. Champia Real Estate Inspections has been working in Atlanta since 1987 and have a great number of positive reviews in their pocket to back their services. Their home inspectors are friendly and adaptable hence they make it easy for the customer to address their issues to them in order to understand the situation completely and take the necessary steps needed. To make it more comforting, they back their services with a number of warranties so that customers can rely on them completely.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. When a person feels that they have a certain type of problem present inside their house and they want to get it fixed, they are always anticipating best services in order to know that their house is perfectly safe and secure for them. People often Google words like home inspection services in maryland to know if they have a reliable source working near them which can provide them the best services available in the market. They also tend to rely on positive word of mouth from their close ones or relatives to check if they have taken these services before and how their experience was. It is always advisable for you in any case that you should opt for certified home inspection gaithersburg md so that you should know that the person coming inside your house is qualified, certified and reliable and you can trust them. We, at Top to Bottom Services, are proud to say that we have all of this and more in the box for you so book an inspection today and leave the rest to us.

    ReplyDelete
  19. There are many problems encountered by residents while living in a house which depicts that the house needs immediate care. Suppose the residents of your house are developing allergic reactions which makes our safe space at home a little hard to live. Home is a place where a person comes after a tiring day but what if he is not getting peace at his own place, what should he do then? A professional home inspection in gaithersburg md is always needed in order to make sure that the house where we are living is safe from all the toxins that may affect our health and all other factors that could cause damage to our property which was built with love and a huge amount of our savings. If you suspect something is present in your house causing your family to develop allergic reactions like stuffiness of nose or sneezing, coughing etc, call top to bottom services today and we will make sure to provide you a thorough home mold inspection in gaithersburg md in order to be sure if this is the problem that has been affecting you or there is something more grave present inside your house that needs immediate attention.

    ReplyDelete
  20. When it comes to our homes and their safety, we always want the best. This condition can be applied anywhere and you will not be surprised to see that this is actually the truth. So if we put the inspection of our house in this list, it is obvious that we want quality home inspection in maryland which will ensure that we are free from all the problems by the end of the whole procedure, no matter how many sessions it takes. Usually it's just one inspection but when there is an issue detected which needs more than one day or requires follow up tests, it can take some time hence we should be confident about the person or company we have chosen to proceed further with the whole process. If a person is looking for a home inspection company that will help him get rid of all the problems related to his house, he definitely wants the best. If he searches words like residential home inspector in gaithersburg md and is unable to decide from a number of options, we are here to make it easy for you. At Top to Bottom Services, there are a number of warranties and guarantees that will assure you that we are in safe hands and your investment on your dear house and the trust you have put in us will not go wasted.

    ReplyDelete
  21. It is a common known fact now that radon is a very harmful gas which can get trapped inside our house and then our lungs if inhaled for a longer period of time and it has known to cause lung cancer in non-smokers. In fact, it is the second leading cause of lung cancer after smoking. Due to this reason and as stated by EPA, radon exposure leading to lung cancer takes around 21000 lives annually which is a very alarming figure and this is the reason that without radon testing inspection in Gaithersburg md is incomplete. When a person is looking for a successful home inspection which will make it easy for him to understand what is wrong with his house and what measures should be taken in order to get rid of the problems found, he looks around for a best home inspector to do it for him, he searches words likehome inspectors gaithersburg md in order to find a best options ar at least some good options to choose from, but we have made it easy for you. At Top to Bottom Services, we ensure that you get the best home inspector who will help you throughout the process and will familiarize you with what is happening and deliver maximum satisfaction. You should put 5% of your trust in us and we will gain the 95% back.

    ReplyDelete
  22. As much as home inspections are important,commercial property inspection in maryland also holds a vast importance as offices are considered to be the second place where people spend most of the time in a day. It is very important to get the place inspected thoroughly as EPA reported around 21000 deaths annually due to radon exposure which causes lung cancer in non-smokers. Radon inspection cost in maryland is nothing as compared to the price you will have to pay when prolonged radon exposure will result in causing major health issues. Radon is a colorless odorless gas present in the air all around us in trace amounts but it becomes a hazard when it gets entrapped inside the house and the residents of the house are exposed to it. The safe levels of radon as suggested by EPA is 4pCi/l and the amount more than it is alarming and you need to install a radon mitigation system at your commercial property as soon as possible.

    ReplyDelete

D&D is a game about resources

Sometimes it pretends to be a game about stories, or adventures, but it isn’t. It’s a game about what you have- hit points, weapons, armor,...