07 July 2019

Can't Stop Thinking About Weapons

Predictably enough, when I set down to whittle the 5e rules down to something that I'm interested in running, one of the first things that I take a look at are the rules for weapons.

Have I actually laid out what my issues with the weapons list in 5e is? It's both boring and long, with obvious traps in damage and functionality, and somehow also lacking in anything resembling interest. If you want to do a big long list of weaponry, you can do better by looking at one of the Warhammer 40k weapon lists, with all of its modifiers and finnicky bonii, or you can look directly at FantasyCraft, which takes great pains to make each weapon type distinct through the liberal use of feats and class features.

5e doesn't do either, which is why I always want to get rid of it. 5e isn't really a game about whether you should bring a sword or an axe or a spear, and I kind of want it to be.



 So here's a little something inspired by much-maligned weapon speed rules in 1E.



Weapon Lengths 


The basic idea is that, in a melee, those with longer weapons get to strike first. They always make the attack roll first. Unfortunately, longer weapons also need more space to operate.

There's also a difference between 'thrusting' and 'swinging' weapons.

Thrusting weapons attack in  a straight line, can skewer through enemies to strike enemies behind them, and can pin enemies to walls.

Swinging weapons, like axes, can cleave through all enemies around them, push enemies away from them in any direction. Unfortunately, if you try and use a swinging weapon in an enclosed space, you suffer disadvantage on your attacks.

Swords, uniquely, can both thrust and swing. They are much more expensive than any other weapon type, however.

So now real-world tactics can apply. If you have a spear, you'll want to line your enemies up behind one another, and fight in narrower corridors where your superior weapon length lets you keep them somewhat at bay. A superior fighter will still overcome you, but at least you have the first strike.

If you're operating mostly on your own, or in disorganized and chaotic melees, you can swing your axe with reckless abandon in a big open area. But tight, confined areas are not great for you. You're at your best with lots of room to manipulate your foes.

If you've got a sword, you can thrust in tight quarters or swing in more open ones. It's not as long as a spear, of course, but you can't have it all.

So now there are tradeoffs and benefits to each type of weapon, and different kinds of warriors are going to want to use different types of weaponry.

I'm still working on how to use skewering, cleaving, pushing, and pinning in 5e. I'm thinking as a bonus to when you beat your enemy's AC by more than 5, you get to use one of your weapon's benefits. So if your enemy's AC is 15 and you roll a 21, you can skewer behind them with your spear, or force them backwards with your axe (possibly off a cliff or into a fire, or whatever). Cleaving lets you hit multiple foes at once. Pinning lets you keep your enemies in place.

Larger enemies need more space, but also always attack first. A giant is going to need a lot of room to swing its club around. Creatures with natural weapons probably don't need a lot of room- that troll sure is dangerous in a cramped warren...

Monks should just flat out be able to strike first, since they're movie martial artists and one has to imagine in a world full of swords they've practiced how to step into a guard or whatever. If you have a different conception of monks in your world, feel free to change this. Maybe they strike like a shortsword. Up to you.

None of this is playtested. Use at your own risk.


This also works pretty well with another system I've been working on, and something I've posted here before:




Weapon Damage by Size

So in this scheme, one-handed weapons do 1d6 damage and two-handed weapons do 1d8 damage. If you're a Fighter, Barbarian, Ranger, or Paladin (the warrior-type classes of 5e), then your one-handed weapons deal 1d8 damage and your two-handed weapons deal 1d10.

Light and/or Finesse weapons drop the size down one die, so a two-handed finesse weapon wielded by a non-warrior deals 1d6 damage, and a Fighter's two-handed hammer toss deals 1d8 damage.

Light weapons can be thrown, and Finesse weapons allow the wielder to choose between Strength and Dexterity when making melee attacks.

Weapons are further differentiated by their critical effects:
Swords and daggers critical on 19-20.
Axes step up their die size on a critical hit (so a two-handed axe crit by a Barbarian deals 1d12 damage)
Blunt weapons stun their foes (DC equal to 10+damage). The wielder may also optionally push / knock that enemy prone.

If you combine the two, I feel like you've got a pretty robust system.

As a DM, you'll need to be fair with adjucating when various weapons will or won't work. Tight spaces can mess with a sword, but being surrounded is bad news for a spear. People can hide underneath things if a reaver with an axe is coming at them, and goblins might retreat into tight warrens to escape a barbarian.


As usual, let me know what you think. I may not respond to many, but I read every single one of them, and it always makes my day to know what people think about what I'm working on.

I'm going to try and be better about sharing what I'm writing about instead of churning endlessly throught Notepad++ tabs, deleting everything, and starting over like I'm accustomed to doing... if for no other reason than maybe sharing some of my ideas can get them to stick a bit.


69 comments:


  1. First National Equities Limited (FNEL) is a leading online stock trading and brokerage firm in Pakistan We bring you the most authentic data and latest updates of PSX.

    pakistan stock exchange live index
    pakistan stock exchange news
    stock exchange brokerage
    stock broker
    trading
    Pakistan share market

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is such an awesome asset, to the point that you are giving and you give it away for nothing. Our article has piqued a lot of positive interest.
    Nice to read your article! I am looking forward to sharing your adventures and experience.
    house for sale in lahore
    house in lahore

    ReplyDelete
  8. <a href="https://chokde.net/%E0%B8%AB%E0%B8%A7%E0%B8%A2%E0%B8%AB%E0%B8%B8%E0%B9%89%E0%B8%99%E0%B9%84%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%A2/>หวยหุ้นไทย</a> NUMBER ONE LOTTERY ONLINE.

    ReplyDelete
  9. superslot Online games that we don't want you to miss because they can actually earn you money in addition to having fun and also getting money to gamble.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Free online slots, PG slots, have access to bet on the most valuable slot games. It is paid out to players in full. Packed with popular slot games that are both fun and highly profitable. Suitable for novice gamblers who do not know how to play online slots games. You can come to learn the game through betting as well. Online slots games nowadays There are more than 100 games for you to play. superSlot

    ReplyDelete
  11. There are many slot games to choose from. Each game will have a different game format. But the method of playing remains the same, which playing slots, if you have a technique to help, will give you more chances to win slots games. Even though slots are easy to play, it is recommended that you play slots with caution Must have a good financial plan. In fact, slots are games that can It can really make money for the players. a lot of people สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  12. make money online With a relatively low amount of funds to bet for new members, it is certainly not dare to bet much, and for players who receive bonuses, we must know how to think over by yourself, by having to meet the conditions that The website has also imposed a minimum withdrawal limit here as most of the newbies tend to have difficulty making their turn because they do not understand how many turn overs you will need to get the bonus. pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  13. Go to the registration page, select the Slotxo game camp, the number one slot game camp.
    Fill in your personal information such as phone number, first name, bank and account number and press next.
    Set a password using 8 or more characters with a mix of lowercase letters, uppercase letters, and numbers. Do not use marks and symbols to set passwords. joker123

    ReplyDelete
  14. with unlimited investment Every system within the website focuses on giving the players as much freedom as possible. Whether it's a subscription by yourself Deposit-withdrawal that can be done by yourself through automatic system. There is no minimum deposit limit. and the maximum withdrawal amount Including many advantages that you will know in this article. superslot

    ReplyDelete
  15. PGSLOT123 is considered the most popular entertainment source. that brings PG camp online slots to choose from to play in full. Just sign up with us and receive a 100% free bonus right away. We have a menu, article, slots, recommending techniques, methods slotxo

    ReplyDelete
  16. there are symbols A, K, Q, J, 10. The helper is the Scatter symbol, vampire mouth and tongue. They appear in rows 3, 4 and 5 บาคาร่า ออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  17. fast and secure It takes less than 1 minute to deposit, players can use it. with playing the game through superslot เครดิตฟรี

    ReplyDelete
  18. Bank accounts can also use True Wallet to deposit money into the game and receive free credit for 24 hours a day, which is a new financial freedom with a deposit system. สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  19. Automated security management, fast deposits and withdrawals.
    has developed a system to meet the needs of customers quickly pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  20. If you have come to the slotxo entrance, players will be able to make money from playing online slots games easily. and more than before with the development of online slots games slotxo

    ReplyDelete
  21. Full service in all aspects Raise the kingdom of online slots, more than 300 games on a single website. pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  22. By the bet, we must have to share the money to play or more. Because there will be a chance that we will be able to do free spins.
    pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  23. the fifth time in 30 years this has happened. Pull it back even further and one finds that in the years between 1927 and 2012, 99 percent of women superslot เครดิตฟรี

    ReplyDelete
  24. one in the casino which is open to many countries especially near We have neighboring countries. ambbet

    ReplyDelete
  25. In the slot game, there are options for both manual and automatic spins. If you want a big jackpot or a very good bonus It is recommended to play by pressing the spin itself is better pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  26. which this big withdrawal amount Just recently withdrawn on February 10, 2022. This withdrawal amount is blind. joker123

    ReplyDelete
  27. Time to come in to play doesn't have to be very long, up to hours to have money out of the game. pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  28. Everyone as well, you can sign up and receive it today 24 hours a day, whether playing through the platform. สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg

    ReplyDelete
  29. selected to play at night because there are fewer competitors to play Therefore, most of you choose to play slots games at night. สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  30. where we have compiled the winning formula of slot games Techniques to win jackpot pgslot เว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  31. that you keep everything confident that it's not someone else's and every stroke is definitely ours สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg

    ReplyDelete
  32. Any betting site, the first factor that should be chosen to play is in the process of signing up for that website. sexybacarat

    ReplyDelete
  33. That is, you can easily deposit money via True Money Wallet. Slots, deposit, withdraw, auto. pgslot เว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  34. For customers who are interested in the game and want the most popular online slot games. ambbet

    ReplyDelete
  35. Our web service provider will develop the system even further. With over 10 years of experience, we will certainly not disappoint our players. amb

    ReplyDelete
  36. should play Many of us who may try to play in the first few months and see why this casino is different from others i pgslot เว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  37. slots of the slot games, just as you can win the slots. But the chances of winning online slots games บาคา

    ReplyDelete
  38. Open a new experience with the most amazing pg slot.
    I must say that the game is the strongest. amb

    ReplyDelete
  39. Try Free Slots There are many games to try out from famous camps such as welcome your สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg

    ReplyDelete
  40. Mastering slots games will give you a good technique and know how to play so that you can easily make profits. pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  41. Through our online slots article menu for 24 hours. Our team has updated the new way of playing, sent directly to the screen. jili slot

    ReplyDelete
  42. to the admin or anything, just top up or notify withdraw and will pass on the website. The system will make the transaction. pgslot เว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  43. That is very popular, breaks often, makes money the fastest. In this article itself. สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  44. Youtube and we've compiled a lot of tips and tricks right now that will make it easy for us to play PG SLOT and earn hundreds of thousands of dollars. pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  45. AMBGiant.com, a website that collects online slot games Lots of hot promotions. The cool thing is that the players are free. Easy to give away for free. Just... Focus on the main Ten and... pgslot เว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  46. And we keep updating new games. Come for you to play always so that you don't miss games from various camps. dooballsod

    ReplyDelete
  47. Learn how to increase your winnings by using our games including web slots today, recommend that everyone pgslot เว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  48. the admin will come to recommend that all players get to know each other. With playing that has been around for a very long time, สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  49. make money online Choose to play on our website, you will find the following advantages pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  50. To the players so well that they almost do not want to stop playing With a game that has a simple gameplay. pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  51. If asked which website is the easiest to break It must be this website. that you don't have to invest a lot but can make money because we dare to give more than others ถ่ายทอดสดบอลวันนี้

    ReplyDelete
  52. Review of the popular PG SLOT slot game today. is a new slot game that is highly popular and responds well to online slots players as well amb

    ReplyDelete
  53. Apply for slots, free credit, SLOT MEGAGAME, new members, deposit only ten baht.welcome ambslot

    ReplyDelete
  54. above. This will give you the opportunity to earn more money by playing. Don't block yourself just pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  55. Modern, aesthetics of the game and hefty payouts Bet as much as you can win hundreds of times more profit. สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  56. The most popular SLOT ONLINE in 2022, full of fun, all games, all game camp's and slotxo

    ReplyDelete
  57. The latest free credit online slots website, just confirming the number can be received. AMBKING

    ReplyDelete
  58. When you apply for AMBBET.BAR today, make your first deposit, get free instantly, free credit. AMBKING

    ReplyDelete
  59. to develop to be interesting The game has beautiful light and sound images. fun to play pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  60. True Money Wallet service provider, top-up, withdraw money, convenient and fastest in 2022 AMBKING

    ReplyDelete
  61. your device automatically Ready to receive full entertainment from a clear live image ดูบอลออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  62. scles to extend their full length. When muscles are strenuously worked they become tight and can pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  63. In addition, the deposit-withdrawal system can also be done comfortably 24 hours a day, like you do not have to walk. AMBKING

    ReplyDelete
  64. Unlimited profits, no round limits at all. If you don't want to miss this great opportunity. dooballsod

    ReplyDelete
  65. recipe room that you like. We will tell you the details about which side you will go on next time and สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  66. boredom because we are packed with fun games and many free credit giveaway activities Apply joker123

    ReplyDelete
  67. game Don't play through an agent. to risk being cheated or deceived You can play on our pgslot

    ReplyDelete
  68. has more than 500 slots to choose from and the most played slots website, whether Is AMBKING

    ReplyDelete

Looking Back

They say that if you don't look back at who who were from a year ago and cringe that you haven't grown enough. What if I look back f...